Skip to content
Why this is needed
The facts are buried in mountains of government documents.

These quizzes turn that material into a quick, engaging way to understand the decisions Berkeley is making — and asking you to make.

The format is fun. The evidence is serious. The decisions are consequential.
The 2026 ballot — and more →

Berkeley Decision Project

Better questions. Better evidence. Better choices.

Berkeley makes consequential public decisions without a consistent method for defining problems, comparing alternatives, understanding costs, and measuring results. This project proposes one.

Public decisions improve when we define the problem before choosing the solution, consider the full range of alternatives, compare costs and consequences over the whole life of a commitment, and measure what actually happens afterward.

01
Define
What problem are we solving?
02
Classify
What role should the City have?
03
Explore
What could solve it?
04
Compare
What are the tradeoffs?
05
Decide
Which choice performs best?
06
Measure
Did it work?
↶ What you measure returns to how you define the next problem.
Before the Council votes on November 17

Happily Never After: A Ferry Tale

Berkeley is being asked to remake an irreplaceable stretch of waterfront for a ferry whose future is far from assured. The pier is built to last fifty years. Operating funds for WETA, the Water Emergency Transportation Authority, run out after 2034. What happens if the ferry succeeds? What happens if it doesn’t?

See the slides →

The Case for Everything Except the Decision

A case study: Councilmember Taplin’s defense of the ferry runs through nine of the ways Berkeley makes expensive decisions without establishing their value, and a decision standard the Council can use before committing.

How should we make decisions?

Start with the role of government

Before asking how to pay for something, ask whether the City must ensure it happens, should pursue it with partners, or should decline, transfer, repair or stop it.

The goal is not less government. It is government capable of doing important things well.

A Strategy for Strategy

The framework.

Prefer slides? View the short version.

Show Your Work

What a recommendation should expose before a vote.

Prefer slides? View the short version.

None of this is radical.

Define the problem. Consider the choices. Understand their consequences. Find out whether the choice worked.

And yet Berkeley repeatedly makes consequential decisions without doing it.

Where does Berkeley go wrong?

These are recurring patterns in Berkeley's own record — not isolated episodes, and not problems that disappear when the officeholders change.

The Crayon Box

Berkeley routinely considers ways to raise more money while leaving ways to change what it spends in the box.

One Hundred Empty Chairs

Berkeley assigns percentage cuts to departments instead of ranking work across the organization, so vacancies and department boundaries take the place of prioritization.

Checkpoints That Don’t Check

Conditions meant to stop or reconsider projects fail to trigger when the conditions arrive.

A Financial Riptide Is Threatening to Reshape Berkeley’s Waterfront

A boating fund pays for the waterfront’s parks, and its shortfall now pushes the City toward a ferry with no nearby riders, at the expense of the recreation the waterfront is for.

Bonds Win Elections; Budget Discipline Does Not

Raising new money creates a visible accomplishment; reallocating existing money does not.

Scrutiny Follows Controversy

Council scrutiny tracks present controversy better than the size or duration of the commitment.

Berkeley’s Hidden Budget Cycle

A second budget cycle appropriates hundreds of millions each year. Council adopts it without discussion.

Which Version, Never Whether

Public engagement often asks residents which option they prefer without offering “don’t do it” as an option.

You Can’t Prioritize What You Can’t Measure

Berkeley measures activity better than outcomes, leaving Council little basis for ranking programs.

If You Build It, a Plan Will Come

Capital projects can advance without first establishing how their ongoing operations will be funded.

Buy Once, Pay Forever

Decisions emphasize acquisition cost while pushing maintenance, subsidies and other lifecycle costs into the future.

Governance by Exhaustion

Council meetings routinely stretch late into the night as elected officials hear hours of repetitive testimony, sometimes on matters over which the City has little or no authority.

Would this actually change anything?

See it applied

Measure U Is T1 Again

What the 2016 voter got for $100 million — and why Measure U repeats the design.

Rather play it? Take the argument as a quiz — the short version, or the full series.

See the analysis →
More worked examples

Fungibility Isn’t Fun

Measure FF added a new stream for streets. The City then removed $3.95 million of committed Measure T1 street funding because “other funding was identified.” The new money stayed dedicated; the old money moved.

Did Berkeley’s City Council vibe its way to a $300 million bond?

Berkeley tested how much voters might tolerate before establishing what the City should buy and can deliver. Walk through the decision process—and the questions that should have come first.

Where Did $300 Million Come From, Anyway?

Berkeley chose the size of Measure U before it finished choosing the projects. When $300 million polled no worse than $200 million, councilmembers treated that as a reason to take the higher amount.

A Capital Bond for a Payroll Problem?

Measure U cites the General Fund deficit, and the City’s plan for it sets aside $40.5 million for staffing (also as a quiz). Voters haven’t been shown how much of that $40.5 million buys new capacity, and how much just moves payroll off a General Fund that can’t pay for it.

Berkeley Wants New Taxes. Its Audit Found a Contracting System Without Basic Controls.

Four unsigned contract amendments worth $500,000 each sat in a box under a desk. In FY2024, 94 contracts worth $43 million had no documented evidence of competition.

Berkeley’s Police Oversight Answers to the Council, Behind Closed Doors

Measure II made the oversight office independent of the City Manager. Its fights over records, its rules and its Director’s job each ended with the Council, two of them in closed session, and none with public reasons.

Fact-Checking the Measure U Debate

The consequential claims from the debate on Berkeley’s $300 million infrastructure bond, each checked against the primary record.

Fact-Checking the Measure V Debate

The consequential claims from the Wellstone Club debate on Berkeley’s half-cent sales tax, each checked against the primary record.

Do the Same Rules Apply?

Berkeley leaders fault Measure Z for missing essential details, safeguards, and risk analysis. What happens when the same standards are applied to Measures U and V—and to their endorsements? A quiz.

What If Hopkins Was the Wrong Question?

Expanding the choice set on a street-safety decision framed as a binary.

Oxford: The Option Not Taken

A ready-made public parcel sold while the City was searching for land.

The Hopkins Street Fire Review

A recommendation whose stated premise was contradicted on the record by the department that owned it, four hours before the vote.

Cutting Without Prioritizing

Every department was asked for the same percentage reduction, even though equal cuts do not have equal consequences.

Every Department for Itself

Across-the-board cuts reward each department for protecting its own turf instead of finding savings across the City.

Where Is the Economic Development Strategy?

Berkeley has an economic-development office and a list of interventions. What it has not shown is a system that says which of them worked.

Berkeley Is Betting Its Budget on Business. Where Is the Economic Strategy?

The Mayor touted 600 new brick-and-mortar businesses. A City-commissioned study found 17% fewer retail establishments and 27% lower real taxable retail sales since 2016. What does that mean for another sales-tax increase?

Policy proposals

General Taxes Are General for a Reason

Voters can support a community purpose without granting every project a permanent claim on general revenue. Here’s a citywide rule for allocating money by priorities, performance, and value.

A Grant Is Not a Business Case

Outside funding changes the price of a proposal. It does not settle whether the City should undertake it—or what taxpayers inherit when the grant ends.

Red-Team the Ballot Measure

Give an independent reviewer one job before a measure reaches the ballot: find the ways its promises can fail while everyone still follows the written rules.

Add an Auditor’s Analysis to Berkeley Ballot Measures

The City Attorney tells voters what a measure legally does. The City Auditor should tell them which promises are binding, measurable, and within the promised audit’s reach.

Make Public Comment Inform the Decision

How Berkeley can preserve public participation without surrendering its attention budget.

Can I try it myself?

Try the decisions yourself

The Berkeley Voter Quiz

Short quizzes on the record behind Berkeley’s November ballot — Measures U, V and Z — with the primary source linked beside every answer.

Berkeley Budget Lab

Protect one service and the savings have to come from another. See what reprioritizing actually requires.

Berkeley Tax Explorer

See what Berkeley’s upcoming tax measures mean for your own household — individually and cumulatively over time.

About this project. Built from Berkeley's primary record: meeting transcripts, agendas, votes, audits, budgets and audited financial statements. Figures are traceable to their sources; unsupported ones are removed.

Berkeley Decision Project and Council Scorecards are related civic projects. They share research and a commitment to documented evidence, but serve different purposes: this project develops better approaches to public decisions; Council Scorecards evaluates elected officials.