Rocky Road streets audit (City Auditor, November 2020)
The City Auditor's audit Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded, published November 19, 2020, with two findings and five recommendations for Public Works, and the City Manager's status reports to the Council on them. On December 15, 2020 the Council approved the Auditor's recommendation that the City Manager report back by June 15, 2021, and every six months thereafter. The City lists four status reports: November 3, 2022, March 19, 2024, December 10, 2024 and October 28, 2025. The October 2025 report says the next status report is expected in Fall 2026. The audit report itself is not in the public-records archive, so its findings and recommendations are recorded here as the status reports print them, and management's original responses are not recorded.
Last reviewed October 30, 2026. Statuses describe the evidence located as of the date shown. A missing update marks a gap in the public record, and work may still have occurred.
On the agenda: Council meeting, May 11, 2021, Item 31 · Council meeting, November 3, 2022, Item 44 · Council meeting, May 23, 2023, Item 26 · Council meeting, March 19, 2024, Item 13 · Council meeting, December 10, 2024, Item 24 · Council meeting, October 28, 2025, Item 35
Public Works will continue to address the remaining two partly implemented recommendations in the street paving audit and the remaining eleven partly implemented recommendations in the fleet audit.Source: Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, October 28, 2025), PDF p. 3, Possible Future Action (City copy)
However, this amount is still less than the estimated $42 million annually needed to achieve the target of an average Pavement Condition Index (PCI) of 70.Source: Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, October 28, 2025), PDF p. 8, Attachment 2, Recommendation 1.2 (City copy)
Commitments and status
Timeline
- November 19, 2020: The City Auditor published the audit report. The audit report is not in the public-records archive; its publication date is as stated in the City's status report.
On November 19, 2020, the City Auditor published the Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded Audit Report, reviewing the funding resources to sufficiently maintain City streets, and asking if Public Works has clear policies and processes to guide paving decisions.
Source: Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, October 28, 2025), PDF p. 1 (City copy) - December 15, 2020: On the Consent Calendar, the Council approved the Auditor's recommendation that the City Manager report back by June 15, 2021, and every six months thereafter.
Action: Approved recommendation.
Source: Annotated Agenda, Berkeley City Council Meeting, Tuesday, December 15, 2020, Consent Calendar, Item 27 (PDF p. 12) (City copy) - December 15, 2020: The City Auditor presented the audit to the City Council.
The City Auditor provided a presentation on her Streets Audit (Item 27)
Source: Annotated Agenda, Berkeley City Council Meeting, Tuesday, December 15, 2020, City Auditor Comments (PDF p. 2) (City copy) - May 11, 2021: The City Auditor submitted an information report titled "Streets Audit Report Wins National Recognition". The Council received and filed it.
Action: Received and filed.
Source: Annotated Agenda — Berkeley City Council regular meeting, 2021-05-11, Information Reports, Item 31 (PDF p. 11) (City copy) - November 3, 2022: The City Manager submitted the first status report on this audit and the Fleet Replacement Fund audit. The Council referred it to the Facilities, Infrastructure, Transportation, Environment & Sustainability Committee. The staff report is not in the public-records archive.
Action: Referred to the Facilities, Infrastructure, Transportation, Environment & Sustainability Committee.
Source: Annotated Agenda — Berkeley City Council regular meeting, 2022-11-03, Information Reports, Item 44 (PDF p. 17) (City copy)Previous reports were issued on November 3, 2022, March 19, 2024, and December 10, 2024.
Source: Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, October 28, 2025), PDF p. 1 (City copy) - April 13, 2023: Public Works presented the status of this audit's and the Fleet Replacement Fund audit's recommendations to the Facilities, Infrastructure, Transportation, Environment & Sustainability Policy Committee.
Public Works Audit Status Reports
Source: Public Works Audit Status Reports (presentation to the Facilities, Infrastructure, Transportation, Environment & Sustainability Policy Committee), PDF pp. 1-6 (City copy) - May 23, 2023: The audit status reports item returned to the Council after review by the Facilities, Infrastructure, Transportation, Environment & Sustainability Committee. On the Consent Calendar, the Council approved the committee's recommendation, whose two referrals concern the vehicle fleet and the vehicle replacement fund.
Action: Approved as recommended by the Facilities, Infrastructure, Transportation, Environment & Sustainability Committee.
Source: Annotated Agenda — Berkeley City Council regular meeting, 2023-05-23, Consent Calendar, Item 26 (PDF p. 10) (City copy) - March 19, 2024: The City Manager submitted the second status report on this audit and the Fleet Replacement Fund audit. The Council received and filed it. The staff report is not in the public-records archive.
Action: Received and filed.
Source: Annotated Agenda — Berkeley City Council regular meeting, 2024-03-19, Information Reports, Item 13 (PDF p. 6) (City copy) - December 10, 2024: The City Manager submitted the third status report. It reports three of the five recommendations implemented and two partly implemented. The Council received and filed it.
As of this report, three recommendations have been implemented and two recommendations have been partly implemented.
Source: Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, December 10, 2024), PDF p. 1 (City copy)Action: Received and filed.
Source: Annotated Agenda — Berkeley City Council regular meeting, 2024-12-10, Information Reports, Item 24 (PDF p. 11) (City copy) - October 28, 2025: The City Manager submitted the fourth status report. It reports all five recommendations implemented, and says the next status report is expected in Fall 2026. The Council received and filed it.
As of this report, all recommendations have been implemented.
Source: Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, October 28, 2025), PDF p. 1 (City copy)The next status report for the fleet and street paving audits are expected to be presented in Fall 2026.
Source: Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, October 28, 2025), PDF p. 2 (City copy)Action: Received and filed.
Source: Annotated Agenda — Berkeley City Council regular meeting, 2025-10-28, Information Reports, Item 35 (PDF p. 14) (City copy)
Findings and recommendations
Finding 1
Without significant additional funding, Berkeley streets will continue to deteriorate and deferred maintenance costs will increase.
Source: Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, December 10, 2024), PDF p. 10, Attachment 2 (City copy)
Recommendation 1.1
Annually, conduct a budget analysis, based on the deferred maintenance needs at that point in time, to determine what level of funding is necessary to achieve the desired goals of the Street Rehabilitation Program. Report findings to City Council. This information will be helpful during updates to the Five-Year Street Rehabilitation Plan and during the budgeting process.
- Addressed to
- Public Works
- Management response
- not in the sources cited
- Implementation date
- not in the sources cited
- Corrective action plan
- not in the sources cited
Source: Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, December 10, 2024), PDF p. 10, Attachment 2 (City copy)
Recommendation 1.2
Identify funding sources to achieve and maintain the goals of the Street Rehabilitation Program.
- Addressed to
- Public Works
- Management response
- not in the sources cited
- Implementation date
- not in the sources cited
- Corrective action plan
- not in the sources cited
Source: Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, December 10, 2024), PDF p. 11, Attachment 2 (City copy)
Finding 2
The Streets Rehabilitation and Repair Policy is out-of-date and Public Works is not following it.
Source: Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, December 10, 2024), PDF p. 11, Attachment 2 (City copy)
Recommendation 2.1
Update the Street Rehabilitation and Repair Policy annually and define who is responsible for ensuring the Policy is updated, as stated in the Policy.
- Addressed to
- Public Works
- Management response
- not in the sources cited
- Implementation date
- not in the sources cited
- Corrective action plan
- not in the sources cited
Source: Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, December 10, 2024), PDF p. 11, Attachment 2 (City copy)
Recommendation 2.2
When updating the Street Rehabilitation and Repair Policy, incorporate equity to align with Vision 2050 and clearly define how it will be applied to the street maintenance and rehabilitation planning process.
- Addressed to
- Public Works
- Management response
- not in the sources cited
- Implementation date
- not in the sources cited
- Corrective action plan
- not in the sources cited
Source: Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, December 10, 2024), PDF p. 12, Attachment 2 (City copy)
Recommendation 2.3
Define goals and performance measures to guide the Street Rehabilitation and Repair Policy and Street Rehabilitation Program that align with other plans and policies relevant to street paving (e.g., Complete Streets Policy, Vision 2050, etc.). Regularly report to Council on performance measures.
- Addressed to
- Public Works
- Management response
- not in the sources cited
- Implementation date
- not in the sources cited
- Corrective action plan
- not in the sources cited
Source: Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, December 10, 2024), PDF p. 12, Attachment 2 (City copy)
Sources
- City of Berkeley, City Clerk Department, Annotated Agenda, Berkeley City Council Meeting, Tuesday, December 15, 2020, December 15, 2020. archived copy · City copy. sha256
0456d05b6c98ee4b…. The archive also holds an earlier copy from the City's former website (bcc-2020-12-15-regular-annotated-agenda). Locators are pages of this PDF. - City of Berkeley, City Clerk Department, Annotated Agenda — Berkeley City Council regular meeting, 2021-05-11, May 11, 2021. archived copy · City copy. sha256
dea69d35db50367f…. - City of Berkeley, City Clerk Department, Annotated Agenda — Berkeley City Council regular meeting, 2022-11-03, November 3, 2022. archived copy · City copy. sha256
3371a279545a367a…. - City of Berkeley, City Clerk Department, Annotated Agenda — Berkeley City Council regular meeting, 2023-05-23, May 23, 2023. archived copy · City copy. sha256
044077e68a16494c…. - City of Berkeley, City Clerk Department, Annotated Agenda — Berkeley City Council regular meeting, 2024-03-19, March 19, 2024. archived copy · City copy. sha256
5cd27624e94b730e…. - City of Berkeley, Office of the City Manager, Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, December 10, 2024), December 10, 2024. archived copy · City copy. sha256
57e0f4e72d1dc4e1…. Information Calendar Item 24, December 10, 2024, submitted by the Director of Public Works. Page locators are pages of this PDF, which the City stamps "Page N of 12". Only the street paving (Rocky Road) parts are cited here, including Attachment 2, the Street Audit Findings and Recommendations Response Report (PDF pp. 10-12). - City of Berkeley, City Clerk Department, Annotated Agenda — Berkeley City Council regular meeting, 2024-12-10, December 10, 2024. archived copy · City copy. sha256
ba81ff85e96f887d…. - City of Berkeley, Office of the City Manager, Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, October 28, 2025), October 28, 2025. archived copy · City copy. sha256
85537acf50afdec5…. Information Calendar Item 35, October 28, 2025, submitted by the Director of Public Works. Page locators are pages of this PDF; the City stamps the first nine "Page N of 9" and the tenth is blank. Only the street paving (Rocky Road) parts are cited here, including Attachment 2, the Street Audit Findings and Recommendations Response Report (PDF pp. 8-9). - City of Berkeley, City Clerk Department, Annotated Agenda — Berkeley City Council regular meeting, 2025-10-28, October 28, 2025. archived copy · City copy. sha256
b8e219c63340a6c1…. - City of Berkeley, Public Works, Public Works Audit Status Reports (presentation to the Facilities, Infrastructure, Transportation, Environment & Sustainability Policy Committee), April 13, 2023. archived copy · City copy. sha256
b841121241b30090…. Item 2, April 13, 2023 committee meeting. Six slides; locators are pages of this PDF. - City of Berkeley, City Auditor, City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, February 19, 2026. City copy. sha256
b8cf23338bc73b58…. Presented to the City Council as Consent Calendar Item 6 on March 10, 2026. Page locators are pages of this PDF, which the City stamps "Page N of 45".
Quoted official records keep the terms they were published under and are not relicensed by this site's content notice.