City Contracts audit (City Auditor, February 2026)
The City Auditor's audit of non-competitive City contracts, its 13 recommendations, City management's responses, and the Council's direction that the City Manager report back on them.
Last reviewed October 28, 2026. Statuses describe the evidence located as of the date shown. A missing update marks a gap in the public record, and work may still have occurred.
On the agenda: Council meeting, March 10, 2026, Item 6
We have not yet confirmed to what extent any recommendations may have been implemented prior to the audit release date.Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 30
Council time on this matter
28 minutes when it was heard, 8 of them public comment.
| Part of the meeting | Topic | Minutes | Public comment (min) | Transcript |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Item 6: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts | Financial audits & procurement | 28 | 8 | 01:45:36–02:13:55 |
Commitments and status
| Commitment and who is responsible | Date, as stated | Current status | What the record says |
|---|---|---|---|
| City Manager report back on the audit recommendations City Manager | Fall 2026, and annually thereafter | Not yet due as of October 28, 2026 | We recommend City Council request that the City Manager report back by Fall 2026, and annually thereafter, regarding the status of our audit recommendations until reported fully implemented by the Finance Department and other relevant departments.Source: Annotated Agenda, Berkeley City Council regular meeting, March 10, 2026, Consent Calendar, Item 6 (City copy) Status history
|
| Put the recycling contracts out to open competition (Recommendation 1.1) Public Works | To be determined | No due date stated as of February 19, 2026 | Will assess and develop timeframe for 2026Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 30 Status history
|
| Align the competition-waiver form with the Purchasing Manual (Recommendation 1.3) Finance Department | November 2025 | Reported complete as of February 19, 2026 | The language in both the Competitive Solicitation Waiver form and the Purchasing Manual has been updated to be consistent.Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 30 Status history
|
| Strengthen ethics standards, including disclosure of relationships with contractors (Recommendation 1.4) City management | To be determined | No due date stated as of February 19, 2026 | Will incorporate into guidance for staff. Will work on solutions for contractor disclosures but need to determine how best to incorporate given potential enforcement challenges.Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 31 Status history
|
| Write a policy on contract amendments, including when to rebid (Recommendation 1.5) Finance Department | November 2025 | Reported complete as of February 19, 2026 | This information is in the updated purchasing manual and the contract training class.Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 31 Status history
|
| Report legal-services contracts and amendments to Council (Recommendation 1.6) City Attorney's Office | April 30, 2026 | No update located as of October 28, 2026 | The City Attorney’s Office will report new legal services contracts and amendments to the City Council on an annual basis beginning with contracts entered into Q1 2026. The reports will not include any confidential or attorney-client privileged information.Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 31 Status history
|
| Adopt an electronic contract management system (Recommendation 2.1) City management | Partially implemented July 2025 | In progress, as reported as of February 19, 2026 | Several departments have implemented Docusign for the full contract routing process (about 65% of city contracts). Citywide, Docusign has been adopted for all extension letters and waivers. There are budget and resource constraints to purchasing software that would integrate with the City’s current financial system. However, a multi departmental work group has been working for several months on bringing electronic contracts management system recommendations to the City Manager for a new system.Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 32 Status history
|
| Track the type of competition used for each contract (Recommendation 2.2) Finance Department | July 2025 | Reported complete as of February 19, 2026 | By implementing Docusign for all waivers, the process itself has all the necessary information to track quantity, date, and all approvals. This solution will not add additional steps, time or expense which is helpful given limited resources and financial constraints. We continue to assess for use in potential new systems.Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 32 Status history
|
| Add amendments, piggybacking, ethics and debarment to the Purchasing Manual (Recommendation 2.3) Finance Department | November 2025 | Reported complete as of February 19, 2026 | The updates have been made.Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 32 Status history
|
| Make the Purchasing Manual and its forms clear and consistent (Recommendation 2.4) Finance Department | Partially implemented | In progress, as reported as of February 19, 2026 | Ongoing process to improve guidelines and process flows.Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 33 Status history
|
| Offer regular procurement training for City staff (Recommendation 2.5) Finance Department | May 2025 | Reported complete as of February 19, 2026 | We have already had several sessions of Contract Training classes and will continue them in 2026.Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 33 Status history
|
| Assess and fill the Finance positions needed for contract oversight (Recommendation 2.6) City management | In process | In progress, as reported as of February 19, 2026 | All vacancies in the Finance Department are in the process of being filled including the General Services Manager and Buyer.Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 33 Status history
|
| Assign responsibility for contractor demographic data and outreach (Recommendation 2.7) City management | September 24, 2025 | Reported complete as of February 19, 2026 | This was assigned to the DEI Officer.Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 34 Status history
|
Timeline
- February 19, 2026: The City Auditor issued the audit report, with 13 recommendations and City management's responses.
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 4 - March 10, 2026: On the Consent Calendar, the City Council approved the Auditor's recommendation that the City Manager report back by Fall 2026 and annually thereafter.
Action: Approved recommendation.
Source: Annotated Agenda, Berkeley City Council regular meeting, March 10, 2026, Consent Calendar, Item 6 (City copy) - March 10, 2026: The City Auditor presented the audit to the City Council.
The City Auditor provided a presentation on the City Contracts audit. 5 speakers.
Source: Annotated Agenda, Berkeley City Council regular meeting, March 10, 2026, City Auditor Comments (City copy) - June 30, 2026: In its FY 2027 audit plan, filed with the City Council on June 30, 2026, the City Auditor scheduled its first follow-up on the audit's recommendations for FY 2027.
The Not Started category includes 19 recommendations from the recently released Homeless Response Team audit and contracts audit, which we will follow up on for the first time in FY 2027.
Source: City Auditor Fiscal Year 2027 Audit Plan, PDF p. 4 (City copy)Action: Received and filed.
Source: Annotated Agenda, Berkeley City Council regular meeting, June 30, 2026, Information Reports, Item 50 (City copy) - June 30, 2026: In its FY 2027 audit plan, filed with the City Council on June 30, 2026, the City Auditor reported that the audit had led to a Councilmember proposal to amend the Municipal Code.
Our contracts audit has already led to a Councilmember proposal to amend the Berkeley Municipal Code to require competition for service contracts greater than $100,000.
Source: City Auditor Fiscal Year 2027 Audit Plan, PDF p. 2 (City copy)Action: Received and filed.
Source: Annotated Agenda, Berkeley City Council regular meeting, June 30, 2026, Information Reports, Item 50 (City copy)
Findings and recommendations
Finding 1
Berkeley spent millions of dollars on non-competitive contracts when competition was likely possible.
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 13
Recommendation 1.1
To ensure Berkeley is getting the best value for recycling services, we recommend that Public Works pursue open competition on the City’s recycling contracts.
- Addressed to
- Public Works
- Management response
- Agree
- Implementation date
- To be determined
- Corrective action plan
- Will assess and develop timeframe for 2026
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 30
Recommendation 1.2
To ensure large contracts have adequate competition, we recommend City Council work with City management and the City Attorney to propose updates to the Berkeley Municipal Code Chapter 7.18 to require competition for service contracts that City Council approves.
- Addressed to
- City Council, City management, City Attorney
- Management response
- To be determined
- Implementation date
- To be determined
- Corrective action plan
- To be determined
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 30
Recommendation 1.3
To ensure clear standards for waiving competition, we recommend that the Finance Department update the waiver of competitive solicitation form to be consistent with the Purchasing Manual.
- Addressed to
- Finance Department
- Management response
- Agree, this was completed in November 2025
- Implementation date
- November 2025
- Corrective action plan
- The language in both the Competitive Solicitation Waiver form and the Purchasing Manual has been updated to be consistent.
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 30
Recommendation 1.4
To ensure transparency, we recommend that City management work with the Finance Department, Human Resources, and the City Attorney’s office to strengthen the City’s existing ethical standards, including guidance for City officials, staff, and contractors regarding disclosing personal, professional, and business relationships.
- Addressed to
- City management, Finance Department, Human Resources, City Attorney's office
- Management response
- Partially agree
- Implementation date
- To be determined
- Corrective action plan
- Will incorporate into guidance for staff. Will work on solutions for contractor disclosures but need to determine how best to incorporate given potential enforcement challenges.
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 31
Recommendation 1.5
To ensure City staff have guidance on how to appropriately use amendments, we recommend that the Finance Department develop and distribute written policies and procedures on contract amendments, including when contracts are required to go back out for competition.
- Addressed to
- Finance Department
- Management response
- Agree
- Implementation date
- November 2025
- Corrective action plan
- This information is in the updated purchasing manual and the contract training class.
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 31
Recommendation 1.6
To increase transparency of spending on legal services contracts, we recommend that the City Attorney’s Office regularly report legal services contracts and amendments to City Council.
- Addressed to
- City Attorney's Office
- Management response
- Agree
- Implementation date
- April 30, 2026
- Corrective action plan
- The City Attorney’s Office will report new legal services contracts and amendments to the City Council on an annual basis beginning with contracts entered into Q1 2026. The reports will not include any confidential or attorney-client privileged information.
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 31
Finding 2
Paper contracts, unclear guidance, and short staffing led to delays and overuse of non-competitive contracts.
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 22
Recommendation 2.1
To increase efficiency and accountability in the contract process, we recommend that City management work with the Finance Department to adopt a comprehensive and integrated electronic contract management system, as funds are available.
- Addressed to
- City management, Finance Department
- Management response
- Agree
- Implementation date
- Partially implemented July 2025
- Corrective action plan
- Several departments have implemented Docusign for the full contract routing process (about 65% of city contracts). Citywide, Docusign has been adopted for all extension letters and waivers. There are budget and resource constraints to purchasing software that would integrate with the City’s current financial system. However, a multi departmental work group has been working for several months on bringing electronic contracts management system recommendations to the City Manager for a new system.
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 32
Recommendation 2.2
To more easily assess the use of non-competitive contracts, we recommend that the Finance Department track what type of competition is used for each contract and maintain documentation in an accessible format as part of the new contract management system.
- Addressed to
- Finance Department
- Management response
- Partially Agree
- Implementation date
- July 2025
- Corrective action plan
- By implementing Docusign for all waivers, the process itself has all the necessary information to track quantity, date, and all approvals. This solution will not add additional steps, time or expense which is helpful given limited resources and financial constraints. We continue to assess for use in potential new systems.
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 32
Recommendation 2.3
To ensure consistent application of standards, we recommend the Finance Department update the Purchasing Manual and any additional guidance documents for staff to include complete sections on key topics such as amendments, piggybacking, ethics, and suspension or debarment of contractors who engage in misconduct.
- Addressed to
- Finance Department
- Management response
- Agree
- Implementation date
- November 2025
- Corrective action plan
- The updates have been made.
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 32
Recommendation 2.4
To ensure clarity in the primary guidance on purchasing for all City staff and consistent application of standards, we recommend the Finance Department work with the City Attorney and City management to update the Purchasing Manual with a table of contents, clear definitions, and consistent language and standards across the Purchasing Manual and related forms, boilerplates, templates, and other additional guidance documents.
- Addressed to
- Finance Department, City Attorney, City management
- Management response
- Agree
- Implementation date
- Partially implemented
- Corrective action plan
- Ongoing process to improve guidelines and process flows.
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 33
Recommendation 2.5
To ensure that City staff know how to use the contracting process correctly and efficiently, we recommend that the Finance Department offer and publicize a regular procurement training program for staff from other departments.
- Addressed to
- Finance Department
- Management response
- Agree
- Implementation date
- May 2025
- Corrective action plan
- We have already had several sessions of Contract Training classes and will continue them in 2026.
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 33
Recommendation 2.6
To ensure adequate resource support for City contracts, we recommend that City management assess Finance Department staff positions needed to provide oversight and prioritize filling these positions when possible.
- Addressed to
- City management
- Management response
- Agree
- Implementation date
- In process
- Corrective action plan
- All vacancies in the Finance Department are in the process of being filled including the General Services Manager and Buyer.
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 33
Recommendation 2.7
To ensure the City makes progress towards promoting fairness in contracts, we recommend that City management formally assign responsibility for managing the demographic data from potential contractors to facilitate data analytics and implementing prior recommendations related to contractor outreach and the contracting process.
- Addressed to
- City management
- Management response
- Agree
- Implementation date
- September 24, 2025
- Corrective action plan
- This was assigned to the DEI Officer.
Source: City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, PDF p. 34
Sources
- City of Berkeley, City Auditor, City Auditor Fiscal Year 2027 Audit Plan, June 30, 2026. archived copy · City copy. sha256
b1828483d850a863…. The plan prints no date. It was Information Report Item 50 at the City Council meeting of June 30, 2026. - City of Berkeley, Office of the City Manager, Audit Status Reports: Fleet Replacement Fund Short Millions and Rocky Road: Berkeley Streets at Risk and Significantly Underfunded (status report, December 10, 2024), December 10, 2024. archived copy · City copy. sha256
57e0f4e72d1dc4e1…. Information Calendar Item 24, December 10, 2024, submitted by the Director of Public Works. Page locators are pages of this PDF, which the City stamps "Page N of 12". Only the street paving (Rocky Road) parts are cited here, including Attachment 2, the Street Audit Findings and Recommendations Response Report (PDF pp. 10-12). - City of Berkeley, City Clerk Department, Annotated Agenda, Berkeley City Council regular meeting, March 10, 2026, March 10, 2026. archived copy · City copy. sha256
354f9f15f290accd…. - City of Berkeley, City Clerk Department, Annotated Agenda, Berkeley City Council regular meeting, June 30, 2026, June 30, 2026. archived copy · City copy. sha256
e351f317c54d69ce…. - City of Berkeley, City Auditor, City Contracts: Outdated Process Led to Non-Competitive Contracts, February 19, 2026. City copy. sha256
b8cf23338bc73b58…. Presented to the City Council as Consent Calendar Item 6 on March 10, 2026. Page locators are pages of this PDF, which the City stamps "Page N of 45".
Quoted official records keep the terms they were published under and are not relicensed by this site's content notice.